The Man Who Shouldn’t Exist

The first thing Daniel noticed was the suitcase.

It was old—scuffed leather, dark brown, the kind you didn’t see anymore unless it belonged to someone who had lived too many lives to care about fashion.

It swung slightly at the side of the man carrying it as he walked down the sidewalk, slow and deliberate, as if each step had been measured years in advance.

Daniel was twenty-five, tired from a long shift at the warehouse, earbuds in, hoodie zipped halfway up against the evening chill. The city hummed around him—car horns, distant sirens, the low rumble of buses braking at intersections.

It was just another American street at dusk, washed in orange light and shadows.

And then his heart stopped.

The man ahead of him wore a long black coat and a black hat pulled low over his face. Broad shoulders. Familiar posture. A slight limp in the right leg.

Daniel’s breath caught in his throat.

“No,” he whispered, slowing down without realizing it. “That’s not possible.”

The man kept walking.

Daniel’s mind raced, memories crashing into one another—hospital hallways that smelled like bleach, a closed casket, his mother collapsing into his arms at the funeral. The official report. The death certificate. The words burned into his brain for ten years.

Deceased.

His father had been pronounced dead when Daniel was fifteen. A car explosion. Closed case. No remains suitable for viewing.

Daniel had lived with that certainty for a decade.

Until now.

The man ahead shifted slightly, and the streetlight caught his profile.

Daniel’s chest tightened so hard it hurt.

“Dad?” The word slipped out before he could stop it.

The man didn’t turn.

Daniel’s pulse thundered in his ears. His legs moved on their own, faster now, shoes slapping against the concrete.

“Dad!” he said again, louder this time.

The man stopped.

For a long second, he didn’t move. The city noise seemed to fade, replaced by a hollow ringing in Daniel’s head.

Slowly, the man turned.

Daniel felt the world tilt.

It was him.

Older. Thinner. Lines carved deep into his face. Gray threading through his dark hair beneath the hat. But the eyes—those sharp, steady eyes Daniel had spent years seeing in his dreams—were unmistakable.

“Dad…?” Daniel breathed. His voice broke. “I thought you were dead.”

The old man stared at him like he was looking at a ghost.

Then his face cracked.

Emotion flooded his features so fast it was painful to watch. His jaw clenched. His eyes shimmered. One hand tightened around the suitcase handle, knuckles turning white.

“Daniel,” the man said softly.

Hearing his name nearly brought Daniel to his knees.

“You’re alive,” Daniel said, stepping closer, afraid the man would vanish if he blinked. “We buried you. Mom—” His throat closed. “Mom cried herself to sleep for years.”

The old man swallowed hard. He looked past Daniel, scanning the street, the storefront windows, the passing cars. Fear flickered across his face.

“I’m sorry, son,” he said, voice low and urgent. “But I can’t explain. Not here.”

Daniel shook his head, disbelief giving way to anger. “You can’t explain? You let us think you were dead. You let us suffer.”

The man’s shoulders sagged. For a moment, he looked every bit his age—tired, haunted, worn down by something far heavier than years.

“I did it to protect you,” he said.

“Protect us from what?” Daniel demanded.

The old man reached out, stopping just short of touching Daniel’s arm, as if he didn’t know whether he was allowed.

“There are people who still think I’m dead,” he said quietly. “And it needs to stay that way.”

Daniel laughed, sharp and broken. “This is insane.”

“I have to go,” the man said, urgency creeping into his voice. “I never should’ve stopped.”

“Go where?” Daniel asked. “You’re not leaving again. Not after this.”

The old man’s gaze softened, pain written into every line of his face.

“I wish things were different,” he said. “But if you stay near me, you’ll be in danger.”

He turned away.

Panic surged through Daniel.

“No,” Daniel said, grabbing his father’s sleeve. “You don’t get to disappear twice.”

The old man froze.

For a heartbeat, Daniel thought he might turn back, pull him into a hug, explain everything. Instead, the man gently pried Daniel’s fingers away.

“Listen to me,” he said, leaning closer, his voice barely above a whisper. “If anyone asks about tonight… you never saw me.”

Daniel stared at him. “What are you talking about?”

The man’s eyes darted to a black SUV idling across the street, its windows tinted too dark to see inside.

Daniel noticed it too.

It had been there when they stopped talking.

The engine revved softly.

Fear crawled up Daniel’s spine.

“Dad,” he said slowly, “what did you do?”

The old man didn’t answer.

He adjusted his hat, lifted the suitcase, and stepped back.

“I love you,” he said. “And I’m sorry.”

Then he turned and walked away, disappearing into the crowd at the corner as the traffic light changed.

“Dad!” Daniel shouted, pushing forward.

A hand grabbed Daniel’s shoulder.

“Hey,” a stranger snapped. “Watch it.”

By the time Daniel shook free and looked back, the sidewalk was empty.

The black SUV rolled forward, merged into traffic, and vanished.

Daniel stood there, heart pounding, staring at nothing.

The impossible had just happened.

Ten minutes later, Daniel was still standing on the same block when his phone buzzed in his pocket.

A text from an unknown number.

You shouldn’t have talked to him.

Daniel’s blood ran cold.

He typed back with shaking fingers.

Who is this?

Three dots appeared. Then vanished. Then another message came through.

If you want answers, don’t tell anyone what you saw tonight. Especially your mother.

Daniel felt sick.

His phone buzzed again.

This was your only warning.

Daniel looked up and down the street, suddenly aware of how exposed he was. The city that had always felt familiar now felt like a maze full of eyes.

His father was alive.

And someone didn’t want Daniel to know why.

As Daniel walked home, one question echoed in his mind, louder with every step:

What kind of secret forces a man to fake his own death… and abandon his family for ten years?

To be continued

Part 2: The Rules of Staying Alive

Daniel didn’t sleep that night.

Every time he closed his eyes, he saw the black coat disappearing into the crowd. The suitcase. The look on his father’s face—fear mixed with love, like a man saying goodbye without permission.

The phone lay on Daniel’s chest, screen dark, heavy as a brick.

You shouldn’t have talked to him.

The message replayed in his mind again and again.

At 3:17 a.m., another text came through.

Rule #1: Don’t go to the police.

Daniel sat up so fast his head spun.

His fingers hovered over the keyboard. He typed, deleted, typed again.

Who are you?

This time, the response came instantly.

Someone who kept him alive.

Daniel’s mouth went dry.

Alive from what?

Three dots blinked. Then stopped.

Minutes passed. Then another message appeared.

If you want him to stay alive, you’ll follow the rules.

Daniel swung his legs off the bed and stood, pacing his small apartment. Outside, the city was quiet, the kind of quiet that felt temporary, like it could shatter at any second.

Rule #2:
Don’t tell your mother.

That one hurt more than Daniel expected.

He pictured his mom at the kitchen table every morning, coffee untouched, staring at the framed photo of his father in uniform. Ten years of grief carved into her face. Ten years of questions she never asked out loud anymore.

Daniel clenched his jaw.

You don’t get to decide that, he typed.

The reply came slower this time.

We already did. Ten years ago.

Daniel stopped pacing.

His chest tightened.

You faked his death.
It wasn’t a question.

Several seconds passed. Long enough for Daniel to imagine someone watching him through the dark window.

We made a decision. He agreed.

Daniel’s hands shook.

Agreed to what? Leaving us?

The response came as a single line.

Agreed to disappear… or watch his family disappear instead.

Daniel sank onto the edge of the bed.

The pieces didn’t fit yet, but the weight of the truth pressed down on him. This wasn’t about a car accident. Or a mistake. Or even crime in the usual sense.

This was something bigger.

Who are “we”? Daniel typed.

No response.

Instead, his phone buzzed with a location pin.

A diner. Twenty minutes away. Off a highway exit most people avoided unless they were desperate or lost.

Be there at 7 a.m. Alone.
Rule #3: If you’re followed, don’t come.

The phone went silent.


The diner smelled like grease and burnt coffee.

Daniel slid into a booth near the back, heart hammering. He’d checked his mirrors the entire drive, circled the block twice, parked two streets away. Paranoia felt ridiculous—until it didn’t.

A man sat across from him without asking.

Mid-forties. Plain clothes. Clean-cut. The kind of face that blended into crowds.

“You shouldn’t have grabbed him last night,” the man said calmly.

Daniel stiffened. “You were there.”

“We were everywhere.”

Daniel leaned forward. “Where is he?”

The man took a sip of coffee. “Safe. For now.”

“For now?” Daniel snapped.

“You reappeared in his life,” the man said. “That complicates things.”

Daniel’s voice dropped. “You don’t get to talk about complications. You took my father.”

The man didn’t flinch. “Your father volunteered.”

“That’s a lie.”

“He chose between a funeral and a massacre,” the man said flatly. “You’d be surprised how quickly people choose.”

Daniel’s stomach twisted. “Massacre?”

The man slid a thin folder across the table.

Inside were photos.

Buildings. Burn marks. Newspaper clippings with black bars covering names. Faces circled in red.

And one photo that made Daniel’s blood run cold.

His father. Younger. Standing beside men Daniel had never seen. All of them serious. All of them armed.

“What is this?” Daniel whispered.

“Your father wasn’t just a man who went to work and came home,” the man said. “He was part of something… classified. Something that went wrong.”

Daniel shook his head. “He worked logistics. He coached my Little League team.”

“He also exposed people who don’t forgive,” the man replied.

Daniel flipped another page.

A list of names.

Some crossed out.

Some not.

“At some point,” the man continued, “your father realized his team was being used. Money was disappearing. Weapons were being moved off-books.”

Daniel’s chest tightened. “So he reported it.”

The man nodded. “He became a problem.”

“So you killed him,” Daniel said bitterly.

“No,” the man said. “We erased him.”

Daniel laughed weakly. “You expect me to believe this?”

The man met his gaze. “Do you believe he’d abandon you if he had a choice?”

Daniel looked back at the photos.

The answer hurt too much to say.

“He’s been moving for ten years,” the man said. “Different cities. Different names. Never staying long enough to be found.”

“Found by who?”

The man closed the folder. “People who don’t text warnings first.”

Daniel swallowed. “Then why come back?”

The man’s expression changed.

“That,” he said, “is what worries us.”

Daniel felt a chill crawl up his spine.

“He wasn’t supposed to contact you,” the man continued. “Seeing you was a mistake.”

Daniel’s voice shook. “Or maybe he wanted to see his son.”

The man stood. “Or maybe something has changed.”

Daniel stood too. “You said he’s safe. I want to see him.”

“No,” the man said immediately.

Daniel clenched his fists. “You don’t own him.”

“We’re the reason he’s breathing,” the man replied. “And the reason you are.”

Daniel stared at him. “You’re threatening me.”

“I’m warning you,” the man said. “Because despite everything… he asked us to.”

Daniel blinked. “He asked you to warn me?”

The man nodded once. “He said if you ever crossed paths, you’d be stubborn. Just like him.”

Daniel’s throat burned.

“Go home,” the man said. “Live your life. Forget last night.”

Daniel shook his head slowly. “I can’t.”

The man sighed. “Then understand this—if you keep digging, you won’t like what you find.”

He turned to leave, then paused.

“One more thing,” he said. “If your father contacts you again… don’t run to him.”

Daniel’s heart pounded. “Why?”

“Because next time,” the man said quietly, “they might follow him instead of watching you.”

The man walked out.

Daniel sat back down, staring at the folder.

Outside, a black SUV rolled past the diner.

Slowly.

Too slowly.

Daniel realized something then—something that made his skin crawl.

His father hadn’t come back by accident.

He had come back because he was running out of time.

And whatever was chasing him… had just noticed Daniel too.

To be continued…

Part 3: (Final Part) The Man Who Shouldn’t Exist

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *